Saturday, March 11, 2006

Cold in the Earth and Fifteen Wild Decembers

I just finished listening to this live on BBC Radio 4. Before I can collect my thoughts and post an entry, I simply have to say this:

I can't understand why people force themselves to assume that experiencing love-as in romantic love as we know it-is the only way Emily Bronte could have writtten Wuthering Heights. Why is Imagination not given enough credit? I agree with Juliet Barker 110%: It is preposterous to even assume that Emily Bronte would have fancied a weavers's son, when she has much more interesting men in her own head!

SERIOUSLY!! Why the hell are people so wrapped up in thinking that one needs to love in order to write such a passionate story??? And Wuthering Heights can be read as something that has little to do with "love", but rather all to do with power and control, as Juliet Barker argues. I think it depends on how one defines "love". But really, Emily Bronte is EMILY BRONTE. I really think she would have demanded more of a man than what was portrayed in this drama. The Robert/Emily affair wasn't even 0.00001% as intense as the Catherine/Heathcliff affair.


I am really sorry she (and the power of her Imagination)is being treated so. Why do people find it so hard to admit that Imagination can be so powerful? Why do people want to reduce this power to the puny effects of conventional romance??
Don't get me wrong...I do think it is possible she might have entertained a love affair, even with a weaver's son. But what I don't like is how little weight Imagination is given. Imagination is better than every living thing. It is the only REAL thing we know about Emily's romantic fancies (she even wrote an Ode to it!). Everything else is mere speculation. Instead of elevating the Imagination, people are trying to lower it by comparing it with earthly-albeit conventional-love.

7 comments:

frankengirl said...

What a magnificent post! YES – to the imagination! I, too, cannot stand how so much emphasis is put on so-called “experience.”

How is it the men can write women heroines, and nobody tells them that they could not possibly write such stories - without being a woman!!!

The absurdity! And does no one remember all the delightful dreams and imaginary friends of childhood which required absolutely no worldly experience at all?!

And why, why, why must we thrust “romance” on women writers, as if their minds would be a barren landscape without it?

Thanks for writing this! Thanks for championing Emily and the Imagination! I cannot possibly add all the exclamations I'm feeling at the moment - :)

mysticgypsy said...

Thank you Frankengirl :)

Exactly! I agree with you. From Homer and Virgil to Thackeray to Wordworth, people tend to praise their works and their Imaginations, whereas women writers are questioned more on their "experience". Emily's Gondalian tales and poems fascinating..because she also fantasized about herself as both men and women. And Wuthering Heights is a living testimony to the power of the Imagination.

It is interesting that while current society seems to be technologically advancing, it still fails to recognize the power of abstraction in art, specially literary Imagination. I think this is a sign that the magic of stories are at risk of being lost..


(I do hope I am wrong though..)

frankengirl said...

I truly enjoy the benefits of technology – hey, I would not be here writing to you! :P But our society expects all this technology to make us more productive than ever - productive in commerce, of course, not Art. Art requires time, space, peace, magic, and Technology is all about speed and non-stop connections. And there is nothing at all Magical about it.

A society without Art is a frightening vision, indeed, like a world without trees (God’s Art?). I do hope people don’t take Art for granted, because, should it disappear, they will miss it, like the oxygen from the trees.

I have faith in the story, though, because I believe it’s a deep human longing to tell, hear, share stories in some form or another. I know some forms seem debasing (reality TV), but hopefully, there will always be those like you who crave a deeper connection to the imagination, and champion artistic and creative story-telling that stimulate our imagination - :)

(Hmm, have I put too much weight on your shoulders, hehe!)

gaohui said...

Bali is another organization that ed hardy Hats are known for their functional yet ed hardy Caps beautiful bras. Founded by Sara ed hardy Hats Stein in 1927.The Wonderbra manufactured by buy ed hardy the Sara Lee Corporation, is a push-up bra that was a sensation during its time. It was a big Ed Hardy Sale success and drew enormous amounts of interest. It was designed to Ed Hardy Swimwear make the bust appear larger, thus enhancing a Ed Hardy Swimwear womans cleavage.Here are more resource articles on cheap plus ed hardy swimsuits size evening gowns and plus size clothing for women.

Anonymous said...

jiang For the quintessential pandora sale Indian bride, the perfect pandora jewellery uk Indian bridal jewelry enhances her looks as much as her make-up does. Her beauty as the blushing bride is amplified not only by the pandora shop kohl around her eyes pandora 2010 and the different hues on her eyelids but also by the eye-catching Indian bridal jewelry that adorns her entire person, from head to toe.Although much of pandora jewelry the Indian bridal jewelry an Indian bride could wear is dependent on the new pandora beads size of her budget, she usually sees to it that she is bedecked with the pandora bead most lavish ones that she could lay her hands on. This is actually part of her presenting herself not only to her husband but also to the public. Because of pandora beads sale this, an Indian bride would want her Indian bridal jewelry custom-designed.An Indian bride would have her Indian bridal jewelry made, based on her wedding pandora glass beads trousseau, especially on its dominant colors. The type of precious metals and stones that will be used in making the jewelry should blend with the colors of pandora style beads her wardrobe.Indian bridal jewelry is not just one piece of jewelry worn by the Indian bride.

每当遇见你 said...

For earrings, you would need ear posts or wires or clip-on bases. pandora shop For bracelets, you need memory wire or stretchy cord or beading wire and clasps. pandora charm For necklaces, memory wire or beading wire, clasps and perhaps pendants. The main reason for the increasing favor shown titanium pandora silver charms is that titanium body jewelry items are about half the weight of equivalent stainless steel items. In addition, titanium can be anodized and this creates a pandora bracelets marvelous variety of colors when contrasted with the single option of stainless steel’pandora bangles s silver appearance. But the markup is much higher. Although the stainless steels used contain some nickel, they don't release nickel salts into the body and therefore are highly pandora necklaces unlikely to lead to nickel contact dermatitis. Most stainless steel body jewelry items are electro-polished. This is a reasonably sophisticated surface finishing technique pandora beads which leaves the finished surface very smooth and free of pandora earrings any crevices or fissures. The result is a significantly higher surface integrity pandora sets which is ideal for body jewelry. Alternatively, titanium has recently pandora bracelet become very popular as a material for body jewelry. In fact, it is challenging stainless steel as the favored metal. A bead board is a good idea too. Its ruled tracks help you measure and lay out designs for pandora bracelet charms bracelets and necklaces; as well as to corral the beads you are working with at a given time.

jiang said...

A good compropmse mght be pandora online something your chikldren want, wich cheap pandora will also be usefdul for them & you. Last year, scooter for one of the pandora charm boys was a big hit as he cuild whistle down the street at him, then fold it & put it in the bag when pandora charms australia he juumped on the bus or want to go inside the shopping center ... Not bad for investment in accordance with $ 100.00. It saved me from going to take him with his bicycle many timse troughout the year. This Christmas does not maztter